Quick thinking, new treatment at HCMC help save toddler’s ear after dog bite
The Riemenschneiders were reeling over their toddler’s bloodied face and lacerated lip when they received another shock in the Children’s Minnesota emergency room in St. Paul.
Two-year-old Kenzie had lost the top third of her ear from a severe dog bite, and a doctor wanted to try an ambitious hyperbaric oxygen therapy to save it.
“We were just adrenaline-driven at that point. I didn’t want anything to do with any decisions,” said the mother, Jaisa Riemenschneider, who recalled thinking, “Let’s just trust the doctor and let’s get going.”
The quick decision proved smart. Surgery reattached the ear fragment after the Nov. 2 injury, and then 40 days of hyperbaric treatments at Hennepin Healthcare in Minneapolis helped it grow healthy blood vessels and return to life.
“Seeing her ear turn gray, then black, and then slowly starting to see skin color come back?” her mother said. “You just never thought that a body part could change colors like that.”
Doctors from both institutions are writing an academic paper to teach others about this promising expansion of hyperbaric medicine — a specialty that increases the lungs’ distribution of oxygen to tissues by placing patients inside sealed, high-air-pressure chambers.
Surgery alone had little chance of success, but Children’s Dr. Siva Chinnadurai believed hyperbaric therapy could improve the odds enough to try it on Kenzie. A similar approach a few weeks earlier had been successful in treating a 10-year-old’s wound but, as far as Chinnadurai knew, that was the world’s first attempt at combining an ear reattachment procedure with hyperbaric treatment.
“The likelihood of healing by just sewing something back on [to the ear] is historically close to zero,” said Chinnadurai, the facial trauma surgery specialist who was on call at Children’s when paramedics brought Kenzie in.
It wasn’t the only fortunate decision. Kenzie’s bloodied face made it difficult to identify the ear wound when paramedics arrived at the family’s home in Houlton, Wis. As they were preparing for the trip to the hospital, one paramedic noticed an ear fragment that fell out of the girl’s sweater and put it on ice.
‘Clock starts ticking’
The general rule is that tissue or skin grafts need to happen within 72 hours to work, but that timeline probably shrinks when dealing with ears, Chinnadurai said.
“You immediately start having cell death right away when the blood supply is interrupted,” he said. “So that clock starts ticking almost right away.”
The top of the ear plays no role in hearing, but there were reasons beyond cosmetics to reattach it. Normal glasses, headphones, masks and other headgear won’t stay on the head without that segment of the ear to anchor them, the doctor said.
Hyperbaric chambers in oceanside hospitals often treat decompression sickness in divers who surface too quickly. HCMC’s unit often treats adults with burn injuries, frostbite, wounds and carbon monoxide poisoning — though one memorable case involved a diver who ascended too quickly from a shipwreck in Lake Superior and spent 53 straight hours in a chamber.
Children, much less toddlers, aren’t common patients in the unit.
“We didn’t know exactly what it was. We were like, ‘Yeah, right. You’re going to stick her in a tube? Good luck,'” said her father, Andy Riemenschneider. “We didn’t know it was a whole room like this.”
HCMC’s unit is the only one open 24 hours a day for emergencies in Minnesota. It features room-sized chambers that are large enough for patients plus nurses or technicians to monitor them during treatments — called dives because they mimic the changing air pressure of deep-sea diving. On the morning after her injury, Kenzie received her first dive with her mother alongside.
Kenzie cried briefly but calmed down; tubes had been implanted in her ears to help her deal with the changing pressure. The biggest challenge was that her mother’s ear pressure failed to level off at the end of the therapy session, and she suffered a bruised ear.
Stress from the ordeal probably didn’t help, she said: “I still had blood in my hair. I hadn’t been home yet.”
A happy patient
After that, Kenzie received treatments with nurses or technicians in the chamber. Her bravery and bubbly nature won over the entire unit. Several caregivers returned off-duty on Tuesday to see her during a return visit.
“She was a dream in the chamber — bonded with all of our nurses,” said Dr. Tom Masters, the hyperbaric medicine specialist who oversaw Kenzie’s treatment. “She did really well. We were concerned about it, but it turned out to be something she could handle.”
Masters used a camera with fluorescent dye to monitor blood flow, and over time 90% of the ear fully healed. A small portion at the top scabbed and fell off. A follow-up cosmetic procedure when Kenzie is older could fix that deformity.
Kenzie is happy back home with her parents and 3-year-old sister, showing few if any signs of mental anguish from the attack or the prolonged treatment.
The puppy that bit Kenzie has been adopted by another family. It was a brief, freak incident that might have occurred when Kenzie accidentally yanked the excited puppy’s collar, her father said. The family still has cats and another puppy. Kenzie plays with the dog — sometimes cautiously.
“She still loves animals,” her father said.