Thirty decades back this week, the bill that became the Countrywide Institutes of Wellness Revitalization Act of 1993 — a recreation changer for research on women’s health and fitness — was released into the U.S. Senate by Sen. Ted Kennedy (D-Mass.). This landmark act has helped appreciably strengthen women’s wellness in the United States and around the planet.
This 7 days would also have been the 50th anniversary of Roe v. Wade experienced it not been overturned past June, catapulting women’s well being and wellbeing treatment into the spotlight and sparking countrywide political discussion about women’s reproductive rights.
2022 was marked by higher aim on health treatment transformation, sparked in portion by the numerous harsh lessons taught by the Covid-19 pandemic. This included figuring out shortcomings in women’s health and fitness treatment, which include gender bias and health inequities, that have extended prevented gals from receiving the good quality care they are worthy of.
ad
Searching forward, I believe that that 2023 could come to be a watershed 12 months that will additional go the needle on women’s health and fitness and health treatment. With ladies building up much more than 50 {35112b74ca1a6bc4decb6697edde3f9edcc1b44915f2ccb9995df8df6b4364bc} of the U.S. population, it is time for women’s well being to be considered a lot more than a area of interest market place. Women’s well being addresses so considerably additional than just reproductive overall health, but for also lengthy it’s been seemed at that way. The capacity to make actual development hinges on wellbeing treatment leaders leaning in — to listen to women of all ages, to determine their troubles and tackle them in meaningful techniques, and to invest in gals and girls business people.
Here’s the shortlist of target spots I really feel are worthy of the greatest amount of money of focus this year to more the transformation of women’s well being treatment and unlock the lots of important options in executing that.
ad
Broadening maternal and reproductive wellness care
The U.S. Supreme Court’s final decision to reverse Roe v. Wade was not just a historic and far-reaching conclusion: it also highlighted the country’s maternal mortality crisis. It is a stark truth that the maternal mortality level in the U.S. is additional than 3 times bigger than in 10 other high-money international locations, like Canada, the United Kingdom, and Germany. Black women are nearly 3 instances much more very likely to die from pregnancy-related issues than white women of all ages are.
The the greater part of being pregnant-associated deaths in the U.S. are preventable. In other phrases, there’s a lot of get the job done to be finished.
Acquiring access to a typical medical professional or position of care is important to assure superior overall health outcomes for gals. However much more than 19 million women of reproductive age in the U.S. dwell in contraceptive deserts, and approximately 1.2 million of them are living in counties devoid of a one wellbeing middle presenting a full vary of contraception choices. Whilst a new ruling from the Food and Drug Administration allowing for retail pharmacies to provide mifepristone will broaden obtain to health care abortion, some states have banned abortion completely. Entry to economical contraception, loved ones scheduling, and maternal well being treatment are critical needs for females across the U.S.
Growing access to psychological overall health means
Covid-19 generated a surge in psychological overall health issues that disproportionately have an effect on women of all ages. According to CARE’s Rapid Gender Investigation, the pandemic’s mental health and fitness influence was three situations bigger on women’s lives than on men’s, with women reporting greater charges of stress and melancholy. This would make feeling, supplied that women of all ages normally faced bigger anxiety and duties through the pandemic, such as modifying to immediate college closures and homeschooling young children although possessing to deal with their very own operate and their family’s psychological responses to the evolving pandemic.
Even as the pandemic started to wind down in 2022, the country’s mental well being disaster continued. In accordance to the American Psychological Association’s 2022 Covid-19 Practitioner Influence Study, need for treatment remained superior for trauma- and stressor-relevant diseases, as effectively as for substance use issues. And practically 50 {35112b74ca1a6bc4decb6697edde3f9edcc1b44915f2ccb9995df8df6b4364bc} of psychological well being care vendors have been unable to meet the desire for procedure.
In 2023, I hope to see far more answers to deal with the range of psychological well being difficulties girls face. As organizations leverage know-how to establish remedies, it is become obvious that partnering with and listening to mental overall health industry experts is what will direct to producing individual basic safety a priority. Also required: addressing the intense scarcity of behavioral wellness suppliers, together with expanding psychological health expert services in the office and enhancing the integration of behavioral overall health into major treatment.
Normalizing ageing
Ladies ought to have to age how they age. Still there’s however a good deal of stigma in the workplace all over menopause and getting older. Girls typically hit the peaks of their professions just as they get started to working experience menopause, forcing them to manage a array of invisible and visible indications, together with hot flashes, temper improvements, and slumber troubles. Quite a few are embarrassed to specific these signs at get the job done owing to fear of being “outed” as menopausal.
That anxiety is warranted. In a 2022 research checking out the stereotypes connected with menopause that was published in the Harvard Company Review, both entire-time personnel and university college students regarded a hypothetical coworker explained as a “menopausal woman” to be considerably less confident and fewer emotionally stable than one particular described as a “middle-aged female.”
But there’s much more to the story. The scientists also observed an efficient system to triumph over this bias: When a lady mentioned that her very hot flashes ended up induced by menopause, she was seen as “more assured, steady, and chief-like” than when she claimed to be “just warm.”
Simply set, normalizing menopause at work by conversing about it can assistance boost perceptions of competence and leadership potential. But this requires businesses to make psychologically risk-free workplaces in which women of all ages really feel snug to explore troubles and inquire for the assistance they require with no panic of discrimination or retribution.
Wellness care reimagined
Ladies make up 60{35112b74ca1a6bc4decb6697edde3f9edcc1b44915f2ccb9995df8df6b4364bc} of America’s workforce. As shoppers, they make far more than 80{35112b74ca1a6bc4decb6697edde3f9edcc1b44915f2ccb9995df8df6b4364bc} of well being care choices — studying, examining, and choosing on the very best program of health and fitness care for them selves as well as for their companions, youngsters, and growing older mothers and fathers. As a person who has worked hard to eliminate unnecessary obstacles to well being treatment during my job, I say it is time to reimagine health and fitness treatment in a way that provides what girls certainly require. I’m self-confident that we will see a lot more progress in this way in 2023, but achieving that goal demands addressing very long-standing gender bias, prioritizing women’s health and fitness, and increasing equitable entry to well being treatment for all girls, irrespective of their race, cash flow, class, or sexual orientation.
The final result will in the long run be improved results for women: imagine decreasing the maternal mortality charge, broadening accessibility to reproductive treatment selections, lowering panic and despair, and normalizing menopause so women can are living more time, much healthier, and far more satisfying life.
Michelle Carnahan is president of 30 Madison, a family of specialized well being treatment models.
First Feeling publication: If you enjoy examining opinion and standpoint essays, get a roundup of each week’s 1st Opinions shipped to your inbox each and every Sunday. Indicator up below.
Editor’s Observe: Dr. Eloise Chapman-Davis is director of gynecologic oncology at NewYork-Presbyterian/Weill Cornell Clinical Heart and Weill Cornell Drugs. Dr. Denise Howard is chief of obstetrics and gynecology at NewYork-Presbyterian Brooklyn Methodist Clinic and a vice chair of obstetrics and gynecology at Weill Cornell Medicine. The sights expressed in this commentary are their very own. Examine extra viewpoint on CNN.
CNN
—
As doctors who focus in women’s reproductive health and fitness, we are on the front lines of a preventable disaster. Visualize managing a female with state-of-the-art cancer who has a five-12 months survival price of 17{35112b74ca1a6bc4decb6697edde3f9edcc1b44915f2ccb9995df8df6b4364bc}, being aware of that she ought to have in no way formulated the lethal condition in the first location.
This is what we are facing with cervical cancer. Still we have the clinical applications not only to lower but also eliminate approximately all the about 14,000 new situations and 4,300 deaths from cervical cancer each and every calendar year.
We have effective screenings: the conventional Pap smear and the HPV take a look at. If these screening checks are irregular, extra assessments can identify who desires further treatment to avert the development of cancer. Importantly, we have the HPV vaccine, which shields from superior-chance human papillomavirus (HPV) kinds that induce the bulk of cervical most cancers instances and is practically 100{35112b74ca1a6bc4decb6697edde3f9edcc1b44915f2ccb9995df8df6b4364bc} successful, according to the Nationwide Cancer Institute.
A report published earlier this thirty day period reveals the vaccine’s huge impression. The US saw a 65{35112b74ca1a6bc4decb6697edde3f9edcc1b44915f2ccb9995df8df6b4364bc} drop in cervical most cancers fees from 2012 by means of 2019 amid women of all ages ages 20-24, the initially to have obtained the vaccine. The vaccine, put together with screening, could wipe out cervical most cancers and make it a illness of the previous.
But the share of girls overdue for their cervical most cancers screening is increasing, and, alarmingly, late-phase scenarios are on the increase.
We have had the heartbreaking experience of looking at mothers in the key of daily life die from this avoidable disorder, leaving smaller young children guiding — even gals who experienced an abnormal screening but never ever obtained abide by-up treatment. It is devastating to see an usually balanced individual slowly and gradually die from a preventable cancer.
Just place, cervical cancer ought to under no circumstances occur. This Cervical Cancer Recognition Thirty day period, we must dedicate to generating that a fact. Right here is what demands to happen.
Eradicating cervical cancer demands motivation at multiple degrees, from community recognition campaigns with culturally correct messaging that broadcasts the energy of the vaccine and screenings to avoid cancer to methods that be certain all ladies have uncomplicated accessibility to plan well being examinations.
Well timed screening reminders and devices to prioritize follow-up treatment are necessary. Way too many ladies with abnormal screenings do not obtain their results, reminders or abide by-up instructions they fully grasp and, consequently really do not receive the right remedy. Obstacles also incorporate logistical worries like transportation and language difficulties. Studies counsel that 13{35112b74ca1a6bc4decb6697edde3f9edcc1b44915f2ccb9995df8df6b4364bc} to 40{35112b74ca1a6bc4decb6697edde3f9edcc1b44915f2ccb9995df8df6b4364bc} of cervical cancer diagnoses outcome from deficiency of abide by-up between women with an irregular screening test.
Gynecology and most important care techniques really should be vigilant about reaching and monitoring sufferers with suspicious take a look at findings. Substantial wellbeing systems can leverage the ability of the electronic wellbeing record to observe abnormal tests and guarantee these gals receive the correct follow-up.
Pediatricians really should really encourage mom and dad of children 9 and older to get the HPV vaccine and tension its safety. About 60{35112b74ca1a6bc4decb6697edde3f9edcc1b44915f2ccb9995df8df6b4364bc} of youngsters are up to date on their HPV vaccines, in accordance to the US Facilities for Condition Control and Avoidance. Medical professionals not recommending the vaccine and parents’ climbing worries about its safety, inspite of far more than 15 yrs of evidence that it is safe and sound and productive, have been cited as major causes why additional children are not obtaining this lifesaving vaccine.
College or university campuses need to do huge-scale, catch-up vaccination outreach. These learners are at large risk for contracting HPV, nonetheless only half report possessing obtained the whole HPV vaccine collection. This service ought to be presented at no value to pupils.
Stark racial disparities also should be tackled. As Black gals doctors, we are frustrated that Black females carry on to be a lot more possible to die from the ailment than any other race, in accordance to the American Cancer Culture. The procedure failures contributing to this tragedy range from Black females acquiring less intense cure to boundaries all around accessibility to cost-effective plan well being treatment and the substantial-excellent, specialized cure necessary to deal with cancer. All people justifies entry to good quality treatment.
Older individuals ought to be informed that acceptance of the HPV vaccine has been extended up to age 45 and to go over with their doctor no matter whether it is proper for them. Insurance policy companies ought to go over the cost of the vaccine for these older ages.
Females must see a gynecologist on a normal foundation effectively into their more mature several years. We see individuals with cervical cancer in their 60s and 70s who have not been screened in 20 several years. Quite a few folks end looking at a gynecologist after childbearing or menopause, but this shouldn’t be the situation. Acquiring excellent gynecological tests in the course of a woman’s daily life is crucial to preserving it.
We also want to empower ladies to be their have advocates by way of overall health schooling. Girls must get their screening final result with an rationalization of what it signifies and any subsequent ways clearly delineated. No information after a screening is not fantastic information. In an perfect globe, girls would see their HPV standing as important facts with the energy to help save their life.
Schooling will make a difference. At NewYork-Presbyterian and Weill Cornell Medicine, we created a series of effortless-to-have an understanding of, publicly accessible video clips on cervical most cancers and the HPV vaccine. We confirmed several of the vaccine video clips to much more than 100 parents in one of our pediatric practices that serves mainly low-profits families as part of a pilot review. Their know-how scores on a questionnaire about the vaccine and HPV that they finished before and right after viewing the films improved approximately 80{35112b74ca1a6bc4decb6697edde3f9edcc1b44915f2ccb9995df8df6b4364bc}, and about 40{35112b74ca1a6bc4decb6697edde3f9edcc1b44915f2ccb9995df8df6b4364bc} of the unvaccinated youngsters gained the HPV vaccine within just 1 month. We goal to increase this effort and hard work.
We have the applications to avoid cervical most cancers but fail to use them successfully. It is unacceptable, and we can no extended dismiss the issue. It is time for a entire-scale offensive focused on all fronts to make cervical most cancers a ailment of the past.
Women’s health concerns will often differ from men’s health. (Stock Image)
This article is for informational purposes only and is not a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis or treatment. Contact a qualified medical professional before engaging in any physical activity, or making any changes to your diet, medication or lifestyle.
While women face many of the same health issues as men, the truth is that your sex can play a critical role in health and aging. Women may be at a higher risk of developing certain conditions. Some common health problems may also affect women differently than men.
Knowing the most common women’s health issues — and how these concerns change over the years — can empower you to make the best diet and lifestyle choices for your future. Here are some of the biggest health concerns for women, broken down by decade.
Mental health is one of the biggest health concerns for women in their 20s. (Photo via Getty Images)
Biggest health concerns for women in their 20s
Melanoma
Melanoma is a dangerous skin cancer that can occur at any stage of life, and the risk increases as we age. However, it’s among the most common cancers for young adults, especially women. Sun damage in your 20s can increase your risk of developing melanoma later in life.
You can start protecting yourself early by avoiding excessive sun exposure or wearing sunscreen. Experts also recommend checking your skin for any unusual spots and regularly visiting a dermatologist for exams.
Mental health
Suicide is a serious issue for young people in their 20s. In Canada, suicide accounts for 25 per cent of all deaths between the ages of 15 and 24. While young men are more likely to die of suicide, women are two to three times more likely to attempt.
Young adults in their 20s are especially vulnerable to mental health issues. More than 13 per cent of Canadians in their 20s reported that their mental health was fair to poor.
Smoking and drinking
While smoking rates have declined for young people, it remains the leading cause of premature death in Canada. Between 2009 and 2016, deaths from alcohol abuse increased 10.5 per cent annually among people 25 to 34-years-old.
The smoking and drinking habits formed in your 20s can affect you later in life. Quitting smoking before age 30 can cut the risk of lung cancer mortality by more than 90 per cent. Heavy alcohol use in your 20s can also factor in developing issues like cancer and liver disease.
It’s possible a woman’s fertility may decrease once they reach their 30s. (Photo via Getty Images)
As we age, metabolism naturally slows down. Women in their 30s may experience weight gain or struggle to lose weight. While it’s not necessarily a sign of a health problem, excessive weight gain can contribute to issues like heart disease, diabetes and infertility problems.
Menopause typically occurs once a woman enters her 40s. (Photo via Getty Images)
Biggest health concerns for women in their 40s
Osteoporosis
Women in their 40s may be at higher risk of osteoporosis, a disease that weakens the bones. About 80 per cent of people living with osteoporosis are women.
Menopause
Menopause is something almost all women go through, usually after the age of 40. While menopause isn’t necessarily a health condition, how it changes your body is linked to other health problems.
After menopause, the ovaries produce less estrogen. Lower estrogen levels can lead to a higher risk of other health conditions. For example, a lack of estrogen may cause a buildup of cholesterol, leading to an increased risk of heart disease. It can also affect your risk of developing osteoporosis, lead poisoning and urinary incontinence.
Breast and ovarian cancers
Women in their 40s are also at a higher risk of certain cancers, including breast and ovarian cancers.
While mental health problems can affect anyone of any age, women in their 50s should be wary of conditions like anxiety and depression. (Photo via Getty Images)
Biggest health concerns for women in their 50s
Colorectal cancer
With 88 per cent of colorectal cancer cases developing in people 50 and older, it’s important to start getting screened for colon cancer in your 50s. This will help you catch it early and increase your chances for effective treatment.
Stress incontinence
Nearly half of women over 50 experience stress incontinence, also known as urinary incontinence. Still, women under 65 are less likely to talk to a doctor about treatment options for stress incontinence. This condition causes urine leakage while laughing, coughing, sneezing or exercising.
Anxiety and depression
Mental health issues can affect all ages. For some individuals, anxiety and depression can emerge later in life. In one study from 2020, 9 per cent of Canadians in their 50s said that their mental health was fair or poor. This was an increase of almost 3 per cent from 2015.
The risk of stroke doubles every decade past the age of 55. (Photo via Getty Images)
Biggest health concerns for women in their 60s
High blood pressure
As we age, our blood vessels become less flexible, putting pressure on the arteries delivering blood throughout the body. That’s why so many people develop high blood pressure as they get older. Roughly 70 per cent of women in their 60s and 70s have this condition.
Heart disease
As women age, plaque buildup in the arteries can lead to heart disease. Women are typically diagnosed with heart disease later in life than men. They’re also less likely to suffer a heart attack, but it’s still a major health concern, especially for women in their 60s.
Women with heart failure also have a 25 per cent higher risk of developing atrial fibrillation, a condition characterized by rapid and irregular heart rhythm that can lead to blood clots in the heart.
Stroke
Strokes can happen at any age, but data shows that the risk of stroke doubles every 10 years after age 55.
Women are disproportionately affected by strokes. Lower estrogen levels may play a role in the cholesterol buildup that can lead to a stroke. In Canada, 45 per cent more women die of a stroke than men.
Nearly everyone who reaches age 70 is affected by hearing loss. (Photo via Getty Images)
Biggest health concerns for women who are 70+
Hearing loss
Hearing loss affects nearly everyone who reaches age 70. In Canada, 94 per cent of people in their 70s reported hearing loss, with another 31 per cent experiencing tinnitus. Hearing loss often occurs as a gradual and natural part of the aging process, but it can also be caused by long-term medical conditions like high blood pressure, heart disease and diabetes.
Cataracts
A gradual loss of visual acuity can be a normal part of aging, but it’s not the only vision problem that may arise in your 70s. Cataracts, or a clouding in the lens of the eye, affect nearly half of all people in their 70s. In the next decade, that number goes up to 68 per cent. If left untreated, cataracts can interfere with vision and even lead to vision loss.
Memory problems
Several conditions, including Alzheimer’s, can cause memory loss in older women. Memory loss and dementia may begin gradually, but over time it can completely impair memory and thinking skills. While there are some factors like age and heredity that you can’t control, experts suggest that a healthy, balanced lifestyle can help.
Mayor Eric Adams reported Tuesday it’s time to conclusion the “taboo” and candidly speak about the “vagina” and women’s overall health.
“We can speak about erectile dysfunction but not clitoral stimulation — something’s improper. Something is just wrong,” Adams explained in his surprise vagina monologue of kinds at Metropolis Hall.
Hizzoner spiced up the conservation as his wellbeing staff announced that the initially-ever availability of abortion tablets at metropolis-operate wellbeing clinics could deliver up to 10,000 healthcare abortions a year — beneath a new contract with a drug producer initially described by The Write-up on Sunday.
“The woman’s entire body is taboo. No one would like to speak about it,” Adams mentioned.
“I’ll in no way ignore when I was conversing about a menopause-pleasant natural environment in Brooklyn Borough Corridor, and all the women came to me and stated, ‘Please do not point out that, really do not converse about it,’” he stated of his time as Brooklyn Borough president.
He ongoing, “And if we just start off getting a conversation — the attractiveness of the bodily anatomy of the female. We are going to lean into that.”
Mayor Eric Adams stated there demands to be much more open chat about women’s overall health.William Farrington
Adams’ deputy mayor for wellbeing and human companies, Anne Williams-Isom, mentioned she was thrilled with her boss’ vagina advocacy.
“The mayor came to me and explained, ‘I think we have to communicate about vaginas more.’ I was like, ‘What?!’ He by no means ceases to amaze me,” Williams-Isom reported.
The mayor’s remarks drew some lighthearted humor from one more gentleman, metropolis Well being Commissioner Ashwin Vasan.
Mayor Adams introduced abortion products would be presented for totally free at town-operate overall health clinics.Kevin C. Downs for The New York
“I know I’m lacking a chromosome. This is why I was at the leading of the stairs,” he quipped in the course of the press conference inside of the Town Hall rotunda.
The mayor was surrounded by the city’s major woman community health officers — which includes Zahirah McNatt and Leslie Hayes from the well being department and Machelle Allen and Wendy Wilcox from NYC Well being + Hospitals, all of whom spoke.
The four wellbeing clinics that will supply the abortion supplements — mifepristone and misoprostol — will be found in the Morrisania area of the Bronx, Jamaica, central Harlem and Crown Heights.
Vasan claimed New York Metropolis will turn out to be the 1st municipality in the state to provide abortion products at its company health and fitness clinics no cost of charge.
Deputy Mayor Anne Williams-Isom backed Eric Adams’ express speak about women’s anatomy. Paul Martinka
Clinical and surgical abortions are currently offered at the city’s community hospitals.
“These 4 web pages can supply up to 10,000 medical abortions a yr, and that’s on best of what our public healthcare facility system previously does,” Vasan explained.
Vasan said any girl from throughout the nation can obtain abortion tablets at the town clinics.
He did not supply a price tag tag when requested how significantly the tablets would expense city taxpayers.
NYC Overall health Commissioner Ashwin Vasan reported up to 10,000 medical abortions could be delivered at city-operate wellness clinics a yr by featuring abortion products totally free of cost.William Farrington
The mayor and City Council authorized a bundle of rules final year to make it simpler for females to entry abortion providers — which include pills to terminate being pregnant — right after the US Supreme Court overturned the Roe v. Wade selection that legalized the federal suitable to abortion, leaving the final decision to the states. Numerous other states are limiting abortions.
Both of those professional-abortion rights and anti-abortion activists concur that New York could be a tourism mecca for females trying to find abortions by making abortion tablets commonly offered.
“Abortion, sadly, is New York’s respond to to everything concerning being pregnant. Abortion is promoted as a social great. Why won’t New York help expecting ladies who desire to maintain their toddlers convey them to expression and escape poverty,” Dennis Poust, executive director of the New York Condition Catholic Conference, said on Sunday.
Condition Conservative Get together chairman Gerald Kassar fumed, “This is abortion tourism. New York has gone way way too excessive on abortion.”
To Help Undo Decades of Systemic Inequity That Have Affected Women’s Health, Mayor Adams Outlines Plans to Create Model for Future of Women’s Health in New York City
Immediate Commitments IncludeRelaunching of a Sexual Education Task Force in All City Schools, Tracking of Health Problems That Affect Women Most, Convening Thought Leaders to Shape Next Steps
NEW YORK – New York City Mayor Eric Adams today outlined his vision for a ‘New York City Women’s Health Agenda’ aimed at dismantling decades of systemic inequity that have negatively impacted the health of women across the five boroughs. Joined by several health care leaders of his administration, Mayor Adams acknowledged the long-standing, persistent problems that plague women’s health care in a live address, and shared plans and ideas to close the gaps caused by long-standing structural inequities, including lack of access to care, lack of inclusion, and lack of innovation.
“For too long health and health care has been centered around men, but that changes today,” said Mayor Adams. “We have been standing on the sidelines of women’s health for too long, and I have personally seen firsthand how the health system is letting our women down. It is long overdue that we break taboos and make New York City a model for the future of women’s health care. We are going to build a city that is here for all women and girls.”
“This agenda will help us, as a city, prioritize and address the health needs of women across the lifespan and elevate the voices of women at every step along the way,” said Deputy Mayor for Health and Human Services Anne Williams-Isom. “The work to implement this agenda has already begun and I look forward to continuing to be part of that effort and doing so alongside so many dedicated and accomplished women inside and outside of government.”
Historically, women’s health has been rife with inequities in many areas ranging from disease prevention to maternity care to mental health and management. For example, in New York City, the average maternal mortality rate among Black pregnant people is more than nine times the rate of white pregnant people. Sadly, many of these deaths of Black people were preventable. Mayor Adams’ vision to create a model for the future of women’s health in New York City includes:
Relaunching the Sexual Education Task Force: Convened by the New York City Commission on Gender Equity, in partnership with the New York City Department of Education (DOE) and the New York City Mayor’s Office of Equity, the task force will educate the youngest New Yorkers and create a culture of sexual wellness and inclusivity. Additionally, the task force will work to update and implement 11 recommendations in its 2018 report — including ensuring school staff have basic competencies around inclusivity and respect and that they can also link students to appropriate sexual health resources outside the school setting, as well as increasing broad community support of sexual health education through public awareness campaigns and information sessions. The task force will also provide an annual report of its activities.
Immediately Committing to Tracking Rates of Different Diseases: Diseases tracked would include cancer, mental health conditions, heart disease, and, possibly, additional conditions, as well as life expectancy and other key indicators differentiated by age, race, and additional key factors. The Adams administration will leverage findings to shape the work that city agencies carry out regarding women’s health. The city will also report on these indicators in an effort to ensure the tracking of progress regarding the state of women’s health in New York City. Additionally, the administration will continue to champion research in this space.
Convening a Variety of Thought Leaders to Create a Robust and Comprehensive Women’s Health Agenda: Thought leaders will include experts from different subject matter areas, including research, public health, health care, business, technology, and more, and will come together for a summit during Women’s History Month in March.
Building on Previous Successes for the City’s Workforce: The city will assemble a committee of experts to build on its past successes already achieved for its workforce, including increasing access to both lactation rooms and paid sick leave for cancer screenings. Work will include examining how to create more menopause-friendly workplaces and promoting access to health services by utilizing WorkWell — the workplace wellness programs specifically created for city employees — as well as other existing avenues. The committee will also look into how the city can achieve or develop accreditations around becoming more health friendly towards women. This effort will make New York City the first city in the nation to begin a framework that is focused on its employees. Recommendations made by this group of experts will additionally inform future work so New York City can become even friendlier to women’s health.
Expanding Access to Medication Abortion at New York City Department of Health and Mental Hygiene (DOHMH) Clinics: Starting tomorrow, the Morrisania Sexual Health Clinic in the Bronx, DOHMH will begin to provide abortion pills to individuals. Several additional neighborhood DOHMH clinics in Crown Heights (Brooklyn), Central Harlem (Manhattan), and Jamaica (Queens) are scheduled to begin dispensing this medication by the end of the year. New York City Health + Hospitals’ (H+H) 11 public hospitals citywide already offer medication abortion.
Launching a Provider Education Campaign on Maternal Health: The campaign will focus on supporting those with hypertension and diabetes and will entail direct outreach to providers in target neighborhoods in the Bronx, Brooklyn, and Manhattan that experience health and other socioeconomic disparities. The 20-week campaign will launch in the summer of 2023.
Launching of a Family-Based Substance Use Disorder Program at H+H: The substance use disorder program will focus on providing support to those who are pregnant and/or parenting and struggling with addiction, while additionally providing their children with mental health support and other services. The program will integrate family medicine, behavioral health, and addiction medicine across a continuum of care. Concurrently, the program will also address primary care, as well as psychosocial and mental health needs of children. In doing so, this model will support the healthy, long-term development of children affected by parental substance abuse.
Committing to Exploring the Expansion of and Access to Pelvic Floor Physical Therapy: Pelvic floor dysfunction can be caused by pregnancy, a traumatic physical incident, age, menopause, or obesity and can lead to a host of problems, including pain and bowel issues. One in three women will experience a pelvic floor disorder in their lifetime.
All these initiatives build off programs and services launched during Mayor Adams’ first year in office, including:
Many women, both in New York City and across the globe, suffer from preventable health conditions and face distinct health challenges. Heart disease continues to be a leading cause of death for women, while breast cancer is the second most common form of cancer for women (after skin cancer) and the second leading cause of cancer deaths among women (after lung cancer). An analysis by DOHMH shows that among women, rates of hypertension are highest among Black women in New York City (41.6 percent) and nationwide (39.9 percent), compared to Latina women (26 percent and 28 percent, respectively), white women (20.6 percent and 25.6 percent, respectively ) and Asian women (13 percent and 21.9 percent, respectively). These inequities stem from a range of causes, including medical training and quality of available services, as well as clinical research historically conducted with men and then having subsequent findings incorrectly applied to women.
“This week is a bitter anniversary as we mark what should have been 50 years of protection of reproductive rights through Roe v. Wade,” said DOHMH Commissioner Dr. Ashwin Vasan. “Rather than focus on what’s lost, we will put our energy toward making gains for women’s health and mobilizing every sector of our city to this cause. As a husband, father of a daughter, ally, and doctor, my hope is that our city will be a beacon for women’s health now and for generations to come. We don’t have another year to wait.”
“Medicine and public health mirror our society where sexism and racism are normalized and it hurts the health of our city and world,” said DOHMH Chief Medical Officer Dr. Michelle Morse,deputy commissioner, Center for Health Equity and Community Wellness. “We cannot simply confront the faults of the past to correct these issues. We must forge ahead with reparative policies and actions. Today’s announcement is one small but important step in that journey.”
“I applaud the mayor for shining a spotlight on the need for sensitive, compassionate, and holistic health care for women,” said H+H Senior Vice President and Chief Medical Officer Machelle Allen, MD. “As a woman of color, I am not only a provider of women’s health care, I am also a consumer. No matter our race, gender identity, religion, physical or cognitive ability, or body type we are not invisible, and we deserve health care that meets our needs.”
“At New York City Health + Hospitals women’s health is foundational to the services we provide every day, and today’s announcement expands the city’s commitment to address the health care needs of those who need it most,” said H+H Chief Women’s Health Officer Wendy Wilcox, MD, MPH, MBA, FACOG. “We will work closely with the city Health Department and all our partners to address the very real barriers that women still face to getting the care they need. The health system proudly provides quality, culturally-responsive health care services to address the gender and racial health care gaps and disparities we know exist at every level.”
“I was inspired to do this work by an African-American pediatrician who showed me that medicine is, above all else, about compassion and really seeing and hearing patients,” said Dr. Leslie Hayes, deputy commissioner, DOHMH Division of Family and Child Health. “Frederick Green, my childhood doctor, made a career journey similar to mine: from private practice rooted in community service to working in government to advocate for children and more equitable care. I am proud to follow in his tradition and to join this administration’s efforts to make medicine and health care better for women, children, and families.”
“This agenda puts women’s health inequities front and center and will lead to inclusive and intersectional strategies that improve health and wellbeing across our city,” said New York City Mayor’s Office of Equity Commissioner Sideya Sherman. “With the launch of the Sexual Education Task Force, we are ensuring young people have the affirming sexual and reproductive health education they need to understand and make informed choices about their bodies.”
“Throughout history, health care policies, protocols, and practices have excluded and marginalized cis- and trans-women and, gender non-binary persons resulting in disparities and inequities, which jeopardize their economic security, safety, and overall well-being, particularly for those who are low-income and persons of color,” said New York City Commission on Gender Equity Executive Director Jacqueline M. Ebanks. “With the launch of the New York City’s Women’s Health Agenda, we change that trajectory and provide better options for all to protect and improve their health.”
“I am thrilled to see Mayor Adams and the city of New York prioritizing the critical issues around women’s health,” said DOE Chancellor David C. Banks. “The majority of our workforce is made up of dedicated women and so many of our students thrive due to the women in their lives. I know that with the focus of the mayor on this issue, we will strengthen our school communities and the future of children in New York City. Furthermore, the children in our schools are our future doctors, nurses, and leaders in medicine, and I am proud of the work the DOE is doing to set our kids and communities up for success.”
“I want to thank Mayor Adams for his efforts in addressing these significant inequities that exist in our health care system,” said U.S. Senator Kirsten Gillibrand. “We have to work at all levels of government to address this very important issue, which is why I introduced bills such as the MOMS Act and the Maternal CARE Act, which work to address the public health care crisis Black mothers face in the U.S. due to deep systemic racial inequities. I will continue to work with all our partners at all levels of government to ensure that every woman receives high-quality health care regardless of race or socioeconomic status.”
“I am pleased to see Mayor Adams take these much-needed steps to dismantle the long-existing health disparities plaguing women throughout our city,” said New York State Assemblymember Rodneyse Bichotte Hermelyn. “As a Black woman and survivor of maternal loss from a health care system that ignored my needs, I’m committed to ending the maternal mortality crisis alongside the Adams administration. Through legislation, including my introduced ‘Mickie’s Law,’ we are ensuring every expectant mother gets the equitable health care treatment they deserve.”
“If we address women’s health in our city, we could save 17,000 lives each year, including an 80{35112b74ca1a6bc4decb6697edde3f9edcc1b44915f2ccb9995df8df6b4364bc} reduction in pregnancy-related deaths,” said New York State Assemblymember Jenifer Rajkumar. “The New York City women’s health agenda is the catalyst for reaching these goals. It will end health inequalities among women, especially women of color, by improving access, quality, training, and inclusion in our health care system. Diseases like breast cancer, cervical cancer, osteoporosis, hypertension, and Type 2 diabetes are often avoidable or manageable in women with proper intervention. Now Mayor Adams — who through the power of his own example showed us the ability to prevent and reverse disease — will ensure that all women have the health care they deserve.”
“I commend the mayor on his commitment to women’s health,” said New York State Senator Jessica Scarcella-Spanton. “Maternal health is a top priority for me and I look forward to having a partner in Mayor Adams to combat this issue, along with many others regarding the health and well-being of New York’s women.”
“Confronting persistent health inequities faced by women in our city has been a policy priority for this women-majority council, and we are encouraged by the administration focusing its agencies to address them,” said New York City Council Speaker Adrienne Adams. “Ensuring healthy communities requires the city making smart investments to expand health care access and services with an intentional focus on equity. We remain prepared to work with Mayor Adams and his administration to tackle the systemic issues that have prevented women in our city from truly accessing the health and safety we deserve.”
“For far too long our health care system has failed to adequately address the health care of women,” said New York City Council Deputy Speaker Diana Ayala. “It’s important that we now begin to take a look at how we can reform our health care system to provide the best care for everyone, regardless of identity.”
“As Co-Chair of the Women’s Caucus, protecting the lives of women and all people with the capacity for pregnancy is a top priority for my colleagues and I,” said New York City Council Member Amanda Farias. “Our country has a maternal health crisis that requires urgent action. New York City is ready to be a leader in the fight for women’s health, as seen in Mayor Adams’ announcement of his administration’s Women’s Health Agenda. The mayor has already been a great partner to the Women’s Caucus, helping us with the shortage of baby formula we saw last year and signing the New York City Abortions Right Act legislative package into law. I look forward to continuing to work with Mayor Adams to execute his agenda for women’s health.”
“Supporting the city’s efforts outlined in the New York City Women’s Health Agenda is of paramount importance and will focus on dismantling systematic inequity gaps that persist in women’s health care. Women of color are historically disproportionately affected by health challenges and conditions, and we must act now to close the gaps found in research, training and in health care services to give the quality care that all women deserve,” said New York City Councilmember Julie Menin.
“Health care is a human right, but for many women, it is challenging to get appropriate, quality care, said New York City Councilmember Lynn Schulman, chair, Health Committee. “As a recent breast cancer survivor, I cannot emphasize enough how important this initiative is and want to thank Mayor Adams for his dedication to the health and well-being of all New Yorkers, and for his focus on the health inequities faced by women, especially women of color.”
“On behalf the Biden-Harris administration, I commend the mayor and his team for their commitment to protecting and expanding reproductive health care access for all New Yorkers,” said Dr. Dara Kass, regional director for Region 2, U.S. Department Health and Human Services. “As an emergency physician and mother, I can attest to how many lives will be impacted by these important programs. We are looking forward to continued partnership with New York on this and so many other pressing health care issues.”
“New York City has become the undeniable hub for startups innovating in women’s health,” said Priyanka Jain, co-founder and CEO, Evvy. “Now, with a city leadership committed to improving access and outcomes, we finally have the opportunity to build the future of women’s health care we all deserve. We look forward to partnering with the city and leaders in medicine and research to accelerate innovation and outcomes.”
“A healthier New York City requires intentional investments in reducing health care disparities that systematically disadvantage Black, Latinx, and marginalized communities,” said Wendy Stark, president and CEO, Planned Parenthood of Greater New York. “This includes ensuring equal access to sexual and reproductive health services and compassionate abortion care. Now more than ever, these services and programs are critical as we face mounting threats to our bodily autonomy and basic human rights. Planned Parenthood of Greater New York applauds the mayor and his team for centering this work and looks forward to continuing its longstanding partnership with the city.”
“New York City’s entire hospital community is deeply committed to ending longstanding women’s health inequities and has already made many positive strides in pursuit of that goal,” said Lloyd C. Bishop, senior vice president and executive director, Center on Community Health Equity Policy and Services, Greater New York Hospital Association. “But there’s more work to be done. We applaud Mayor Adams for his leadership and vision, and we look forward to partnering with his administration on this important issue.”
“The Mothership is honored to be serving as part of Mayor Adam’s Citywide Doula Initiative, working to protect and uphold respectful birthing care as a human right for Black and Brown families in Harlem, Inwood, and Washington Heights,” said Miranda Padilla, founder, The Mothership. “Racial health inequities stem from deep rooted systemic racism. Accessible doula care for all is a step forward in the fight for reproductive justice. We at The Mothership are grateful to be able to do the work in our community, treating childbirth as the sacred, transformative, healing, physiological process that it is, while challenging the status quo and reproductive health systems in place.”
“We are in a part of the world that values rugged individualism, and yet the way most individuals thrive is by being in strong communities,” said Coleen Stevens Porchér, executive director, Power of Two NYC. “For hundreds of years, people of African ancestry have lived by the adage, ‘it takes a village to raise children,’ but many women often feel as if they are the sole members of the community of child rearers. Parenting is both rewarding and hard work, and no one tells you that or can adequately prepare you for it. Since we know the personal, economic, physical, mental, and emotional toll it can take, we ought to do everything possible to remove barriers, address inequity, and ensure that women get the support they need and that will make them and their families thrive.”
“The Bronx has the highest rates of maternal morbidity in New York City along with highest rates of infant mortality,” said Paulette Zalduondo Henriquez, executive director, Bronx Health Link. “We are grateful to Mayor Adams for supporting more women of color. The Bronx Health Link looks forward to ongoing collaboration with Mayor Adams and our responsive historic Borough President Vanessa Gibson who has made funding available while at the New York City Council to tackle this problem which is literally a matter of life or death.”
“The Staten Island Partnership for Community Wellness applauds Mayor Adams for prioritizing women’s health and wellness and ensuring women have access to needed reproductive health services throughout the entire city,” said Adrienne Abbate, executive director, Staten Island Partnership for Community Wellness. “We are eager to partner with his administration to address the systemic issues that contribute to poor maternal and infant outcomes for New York City’s most marginalized communities.”
“New York City can only be as strong as the health of the millions of women and girls who live and work here and make this place the ever-resilient and thriving urban center we are. I am very pleased to see the administration taking steps to prioritize the health, wellbeing and reproductive autonomy of our women and girls, including expanding the accessibility of medication abortion across all boroughs, and relaunching the city’s Sexual Education Task Force,” said Dr. Herminia Palacio, former New York City deputy mayor for health and human services; and current president and CEO, The Guttmacher Institute.
“Mama Glow is proud to work with the Mayor’s Office and the city of New York to address the health care system’s inequities impacting Black and Brown birthing people by advancing innovative policies and programs like the Citywide Doula Initiative (CDI),” said Latham Thomas, founder, Mama Glow and the Mama Glow Foundation. “The CDI serves as a model for what other metropolitan cities nationwide could embrace and replicate to address decades-long systemic inequalities for marginalized people and enable real change for womxn’s reproductive rights.”
One woman was told she was being “dramatic” when she pleaded for a brain scan after suffering months of headaches and pounding in her ears. It turned out she had a brain tumor.
Another was ignored as she cried out in pain during a 33-hour labor. She was supposed to be getting pain medication through her epidural, but it had fallen out.
Dozens of women complained of torturous pain as their vaginal walls were punctured during an egg retrieval process. They were told their pain was normal, but, in actuality, they were getting saline instead of anesthesia.
These are just some of the stories of women who say their pain and suffering has been dismissed or misdiagnosed by doctors. Although these are anecdotal reports, a number of studies support the claim that women in pain oftenare not taken as seriously as men.
Story continues below advertisement
Story continues below advertisement
This year, the Journal of the American Heart Association reported that women who visited emergency departments with chest pain waited 29 percent longer than men to be evaluated for possible heart attacks.
An analysis of 981 emergency room visits showed that women with acute abdominal pain were up to 25 percent less likely than their male counterparts to be treated with powerful opioid painkillers.
“I was told I knew too much, that I was working too hard, that I was stressed out, that I was anxious,” said Ilene Ruhoy, a 53-year-old neurologist from Seattle, who had head pain and pounding in her ears.
Despite having a medical degree, Ruhoy said she struggled to get doctors to order a brain scan. By the time she got it in 2015, a tennis ball-sized tumor was pushing her brain to one side. She needed surgery, but first, she rushed home, hugged her 11-year-old daughter and wrote her a letter to tell her goodbye.
Ruhoy did not die on the operating table, but her tumor had grown so large it could not be entirely removed. Now, she has several smaller tumors that require radiation treatment.
She said many of her female patients have had experiences similar to hers. “They’re not validated with regards to their concerns; they’re gaslit; they’re not understood,” she said. “They feel like no one is listening to them.”
Research also suggests that women are more sensitive to pain than men and are more likely to express it, so their pain is often seen as an overreaction rather than a reality, said Roger Fillingim, director of the Pain Research and Intervention Center of Excellence at the University of Florida.
Fillingim, who co-wrote a review article on sex differences in pain, said there are many possible explanations, including hormones, genetics and even social factors such as gender roles.
Regardless, he said, “you treat the pain that the patient has, not the pain that you think the patient should have.”
(Illustration by Vanessa Saba for The Washington Post/Photos: Getty Images)
Women say reproductive health complaints are commonly ignored
When Molly Hill made an appointment at a Connecticut clinic in 2017 to get an IUD, she said she was warned it would be uncomfortable, but she was not prepared for “horrific” pain. Hill, now 27 and living in San Francisco, recalled that during the procedure, she began crying in pain and shouted at the doctor to stop.
“We’re almost done,” she said the doctor told her and continued the procedure.
“It was full-body, electrifying, knife-stabbing pain,” she said. After it was done, she said she lay sobbing on the table in physical and emotional pain. “It felt violating, too, to have that pain that deep in your core where you feel the most vulnerable.”
Would you like to share your own experiences of coping with pain and navigating the medical system? Fill out this form, and we may include you in a collection of reader stories.
My wife of 35 years complained of intense abdominal pain for over 5 years. She was dismissed. My wife returned home from work and begged me to take her to the ER because her pain was unberaable. In the hospital a female physician’s assistant did what multiple doctors had not done: She believed my wife. After a series of tests, she diagnosed Stage 3 ovarian cancer, and 18 months later, my wife died.
Mick, South Carolina, 69
I was told for 15 years that what turned out to be super-ventricular tachycardia was “anxiety attacks.” It finally took a female nurse at the school I worked for to put a blood pressure cuff and blood oxygen reader on me to realize I had a bigger issue.
Angelina, New Jersey, 27
I had a uterine biopsy to rule out cancer. Women are typically not given any kind of anesthesia or pain relief for this procedure. The pain was so intense that I couldn’t keep myself from screaming. I asked my doctor afterward why they don’t administer any sort of anesthesia for that procedure, and the answer was, “We just don’t.”
Jeanna, Georgia, 46
I started to experience strange sensations along my face, extending along the right side of my body. My GP laughed and said, “What do you want me to do, order a total body neurological work up?” At the same time, I complained to my eye doctor I was experiencing double vision and blurriness. I joked it was a brain tumor; they reassured me it was not. Six months later I lost consciousness and had an MRI. It was a brain tumor.
Anne, Maryland, 60
I, too, had extreme pain from an IUD insertion. I passed out on the table and was awakened by a nurse telling me to hurry and get dressed because they needed the room.
Margaret , CA, 70
I was 45 when I consulted a GYN about cramping pain and excessive bleeding. He told me I was being mildly inconvenienced by perimenopause. A year later, when I changed medical insurance, I learned I had endometrial cancer.
Diane, NY, 68
It saddens me that this is still an issue so many years after I experienced it myself. In the early 1960’s, at the age of 29, I developed a gastric ulcer. My doctor refused to believe it was anything more than ”heartburn.“ I lost weight and suffered for an entire year before my doctor reluctantly ordered tests. I am now 89 years old and remember this as one of the worst periods of my life.
Jean, Maryland, 89
I was having an emergency C-section and could feel every cut my doctor made. It was excruciating. I was screaming and my female doctor stopped and instructed the male anesthesiologist to up my pain meds. Instead of addressing me, he turned to my husband and said “All she’s feeling is pressure. And pressure feels like pain to some people.” Luckily my doctor insisted he up the dosage. Her subsequent cuts started feeling less painful.
Lauren, PA, 35
End of carousel
Studies consistently show that women who have not experienced vaginal birth have much higher pain during IUD insertion compared with women who have given birth. A Swedish study found that among 224 women who had not given birth, 89 percent reported moderate or severe pain. One in six of the women said the pain was severe.
Although numbing agents and local anesthetics are available, they are rarely used.
In some cases, women have sued physicians for ignoring their pain. Dozens of women sued Yale University claiming that during an egg harvesting procedure at its infertility clinic, they were supposed to be receiving the powerful painkiller fentanyl. But some women were getting only diluted pain medication or none at all, according to lawsuits filed in the state Superior Court in Connecticut.
Later, the clinic discovered a nurse had been stealing vials of fentanyl and replacing the painkiller with saline solution. The nurse pleaded guilty last year and was sentenced for tampering with the drugs.
One of the plaintiffs, Laura Czar, wrote about her experience for Elle magazine, describing it as “a horrible, gut-wrenching pain,” and told a doctor at the time, “I can feel everything you’re doing.” Despite her protests, the doctor continued.
Yale said in a statement that it “deeply regrets” the women’s distress and has “reviewed its procedures and made changes to further oversight of pain control and controlled substances.”
(Illustration by Vanessa Saba for The Washington Post/Photos: Unsplash, Pexels)
Racial disparities in pain management
For Sharee Turpin, the pain of sickle-cell diseasesometimes feels like tiny knives slicing her open. Sickle cell disease is an inherited blood disorder that can cause suffering so severe, its attacks are called “pain crises.”
But when Turpin, who is Black, experiences a pain crisis, the 34-year-old does not rush to the ER in Rochester, N.Y. Instead, she combs her hair, mists some perfume and slips on her “Sunday best” in hopes that the doctors and nurses won’t peg her as a drug seeker, she said.
Sometimes, Turpin gets a care team that understands her pain. Other times, she is treated as a bother. “I’ve even been told ‘shut up’ by a nurse because I was screaming too loud while I was in pain,” she said.
Story continues below advertisement
Story continues below advertisement
Abundant research shows racial bias in pain treatment. A 2016 study found half of white medical students and residents held at least one false belief about biological differences between Blacks and Whites, and were more likely to underestimate Black patients’ pain.
“The management of pain is one of the largest disparities that we see between Black people and White people in the American health-care system,” said Tina Sacks, an associate professor at the University of California at Berkeley and author of “Invisible Visits: Black Middle-Class Women in the American Healthcare System.”
Labeling women “hysterical” or blaming psychological causes
Research shows men in chronic pain tend to be regarded as “stoic” while women are more likely to be considered “emotional” and “hysterical” and accused of “fabricating the pain.”
Carol Klay, a 68-year-old from Tampa, had endured years of chronic pain from arthritis, degenerative disk disease and spinal stenosis. During a hospital stay last year, her doctor noted in her medical record that she was crying “hysterically.”
Klay said she was crying because she was unable to sit, stand or walk without agony, and the doctor had removed morphine from her cocktail of pain medications. She wonders whether the doctor “would have called me hysterical if I was a man,” she said.
Tampa General Hospital said it could not discuss specific patients, but stated: “Patient treatment plans, including medication orders to reduce pain, are prescribed by multi-disciplinary clinical teams.”
Research shows women’s physical pain is also often attributed to psychological causes.
Story continues below advertisement
Story continues below advertisement
Jan Maderios, a 72-year-old Air Force veteran from Chipley, Fla.,said the trauma of having pain dismissed by doctors has stayed with her for years. She saw about a dozen doctors in the early 1970s for pelvic pain. When clinicians could not identify the cause of her pain, she was referred to a psychiatrist.
“You start to doubt yourself after so many medical experts tell you there’s nothing wrong with you,” she said.
After a hysterectomy in 1976, Maderios learned that fibroid tumors in her uterus had been the source of her pain. She said learning her pain was real — and physical — “made all the difference in the world.”
(Illustration by Vanessa Saba for The Washington Post/Photos: iStock, Unsplash)
Why women’s pain complaints often aren’t taken seriously
During a 33-hour labor with her first child in 2011, Anushay Hossain, 42, of D.C., opted for epidural pain relief but said she stillfelt it all — every contraction, every cramp and every dismissal of her pain by her medical team. The doctor reassured her that she was getting the maximum dosage of pain medication.
In fact, she wasn’t getting any at all. She said her epidural had slipped out. By the time the error was caught, she was shaking uncontrollably and in need of an emergency Caesarean section, she said.
This pain gap may stem, in part, from the fact that women have historically been excluded from medical research. It wasn’t until 2016 that the National Institutes of Health (NIH) required sex to be considered as a biological variable in most studies it funded.
“We’re making progress,” said David Thomas, special adviser to the director of NIH’s Office of Research on Women’s Health. “But we do have a long way to go because there’s this whole institutional approach to doing research — pain and beyond — where it tends to be male-focused.”
Nearly 95 percent of U.S. medical school students said instruction on sex and gender differences in medicine should be included in curriculums, according to a 2015 survey. But only 43 percent said their curriculum had helped them understand those differences and only 34.5 percent said they felt prepared to manage them in a health-care setting.
Story continues below advertisement
Story continues below advertisement
“It is changing, but it’s changing very slowly,” said Janice Werbinski, immediate past president of the American Medical Women’s Association and chair of the mentorship committee of the association’s Sex and Gender Health Collaborative.
How women can advocate for better pain care
It took decades to solve the mystery of Maureen Woods’s chronic pain. Woods, 64, of Myersville, Md., started having joint pain in her teens and, over the years, told dozens of doctors her pain was “debilitating,” she said. Some told her it was all in her head. In 2017, she was diagnosed with hypermobile Ehlers-Danlos syndrome, a connective tissue disorder often causing loose joints, dislocations and chronic pain.
She said women who are not being heard should keep advocating for themselves. “You have to go with your gut — something is wrong and I need to find a doctor who can figure it out,” she said.
Marjorie Jenkins, dean of the University of South Carolina School of Medicine Greenville, urged women against feeling pressured to accept an “everything is normal” non-diagnosis.
Story continues below advertisement
Story continues below advertisement
“If your provider does not appear to be listening to you or believing what you’re saying, then you need a new provider,” Jenkins said. “You are the client, you are the customer and you are the owner of your health.”
Particularly in emergency departments, she said, there can be an inherent bias. “There’s this assumption that women are emotional and they’re anxious and that that’s the main issue,” she said.
[Sign up for the Well+Being newsletter, your source of expert advice and simple tips to help you live well every day]